Earlier this month I posted that I would be trying out a Matt Cutts’-style 30 Day Challenge, trying to use the Chromebook as my primary computing device for the month of July. I purchased the HP Chromebook 14 a few months ago and made it my goal to use the device as often as possible in my daily computing, both at home and at work.
Like many school districts, we are a Microsoft shop, so I was especially curious how the Chromebook would interact with my work environment. For the most part, the entire experience worked incredibly well.
First, about the device: The HP Chromebook 14 is a very nice device. On my desk at work I have 2 18-inch monitors, so lots of screen real estate. I also have an iPad with Retina (Gen 3) and an original Surface Pro, each of which have much less screen real estate. The HP Chromebook 14 has a very nice 14-inch screen that is much larger than my Surface Pro. Granted, I would never want a 14-inch tablet, so the form factor makes sense for each device. I love my Surface Pro, but often want for a slightly larger screen. The HP Chromebook 14 screen is pretty large, but more importantly from a productivity standpoint, this leads to a nicely-spaced keyboard (no number keypad, but that’s fine with me). With the larger screen and keyboard also brings a large battery inside, and this device has excellent battery life. Only once have I opened it up from being in my bag and found it with less than 10% battery life. The product page mentions up to 9.5 hours of battery, and I’ve found this to be true. The trackpad is very nice (better than any Windows machine I’ve ever used at twice the price-point of this Chromebook), and that is a major plus for the device. I’ve not needed to use the USB ports (it has both 3.0 and 2.0 ports), the SD card slot, or the HDMI port. Sound from the speakers is fine, but not a highlight like the battery life or trackpad.
No device is perfect, and the HP Chromebook 14 is the same for me. My biggest problem with the device is the weight. It comes in at barely over 4 pounds, which compared to my iPad or Surface Pro, is really heavy. I know it’s all because of the battery and screen size, and I’ve really become spoiled with simply picking up either of the other devices and walking down the hall to someone’s office or into someone’s classroom, but the weight (and in turn probably the large size) has made me begrudgingly pick up the Chromebook and walk with it. I also struggled with the fact that I couldn’t access network resources (network storage and some printers), which really hurt productivity when I’m the only one in the district trying this. Printing was able to work using Google Print, but that still required me to use my Windows PC, and was still kinda flaky when I use it: setup was much more difficult for me than it seemed like it should have been, and printing was very delayed for me as well. My district version of Outlook Web Access only allowed me to use the Light version, which is so stripped down as to be nearly useless, and this was probably my biggest pain-point during the challenge. Honestly, I cheated for some more complex email searching needs and jumped over to my Windows PC. I also needed to Remote Desktop into my work PC while on vacation, and while ChromeOS does have that capability available, I just used my Surface Pro and TeamViewer to do that work for about 20 minutes.
As to the classroom with students, I think the device would be very good for many students. Chrome OS has become very capable in the last 12 months. As I type this post, I have Tweetdeck scrolling on the right 25% of the screen and WordPress open in the other 75%. Window Snapping works very similarly as in Windows 7/8, and I use that feature alone many times a day. I think this is a huge productivity feature that is missing on iPad and Android devices, so to have it on a laptop is essential, especially with the 14″ screen. I believe that students can use most any device in the classroom with a smaller learning curve than most teachers, so ultimately the device choice should be heavily influenced by teacher requests. I live in the Chrome browser at work, with the exception of Office products and TechSmith Snagit and Camtasia. There is a SnagIt extension for ChromeOS for both video and screenshots, but I can’t use the screen capture across multiple browser windows. That is a very minor issue, and perfectly useable. Even Office 365 works incredibly well in Chrome, and I completed my productivity work in Word and Excel online, seamlessly saving to OneDrive, which then magically updated on my Windows PC.
I still have a week left in this challenge, but I’ve confirmed my beliefs that the Chromebook could easily be the primary computer for a large percentage of people. A school visit to Richland Two in Columbia, South Carolina, a few years ago changed my mind on how the devices could be used in schools, and putting my hands on one for an extended period of time this month made that even more apparent. I’m excited to use it even more in the future.